Lillian Pizzeria: A Slice of Forest Hills' Best Pizza and Italian Eats

Went for the classic New York slices and liked them enough to make it my toddlers first NYC slice! So now we have history so have to come back again. Ray Romano eats here too based on the pic on the wall. He's Italian too, I think...so it must be legit, right? But enough about Ray, you wanna know about the pizza. The slices are good says my wife, a new Yorker of 30 years. That's good enough for me. But hold up, we also got the grandma slice on a whim. Whoa! I liked the regular slices. But I LOVED the grandma slice! It was one of the best I have ever had. The owner was kind and friendly in the most new Yorker kinda way. Sounded like Jon Stewart but Italian. I dig it. The guys working the kitchen messed up on our order. Once they realized their mistake, they fixed it by giving us the correct slices, letting us keep the wrong ones on the house. I'll be back.

Solid New York Pizza, The Sauce reminds me of Angelo's that used to be on Main Street back in the day. Definitely an old-school flavor with good ingredients. Pizza looked right and was cooked right. The place definitely has some nostalgia as it has been here for many years. I would recommend the Sicilian over the regular slice though. 4 stars, not the best but definitely not the worst

A+ again. The grandma pies are amazing. Broccoli pinwheels are my daughter’s favorite- a classic! Chicken wings are on point

Definitely five stars. I came here almost when they closed the door, but they are so welcoming and friendly . The pizza comes out perfect and quickly, soooo delicious and crispy, I love it. The broccoli pinwheel is my favorite. I am glad to find this place and would back again. Strong recommend.

Nice neighborhood location tucked away from all the craziness but can do so much better with interior atmosphere. The service if ordering and dining in person can be non existent or unappreciated. The pasta dishes and the pizzas are delicious and the delivery drivers are very polite and courteous.

This a great neighborhood pizza joint. Solid pizza with good traditional flavors. The staff is friendly and they seem like they are having fun.

Simple old-school Queens pizzeria. This is Ray Romano's favorite pizzeria. Regular triangle slice is good but their Sicilans are great. Fairly priced as well. Give them a shot I highly recommend it.

Absolutely loved Lillian’s Pizzeria in Forest Hills! The food is outstanding—each bite was full of flavor and you can tell they use top-quality ingredients. The pizza was perfectly crispy, with just the right amount of cheese and sauce. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, making it a great spot to relax and enjoy a meal with friends or family. The staff was friendly and attentive, adding to the overall fantastic experience. Definitely a five-star gem in Queens!